Former police chief has questions about probe into death of Ala. shooting suspect’s brother

Ex-chief now questions ‘86 Bishop shooting probe

BRAINTREE, Mass. — A former suburban Boston police chief now says he has serious questions about the investigation done when an accused university shooter killed her brother in 1986.

Amy Bishop is accused of shooting six colleagues, three of them fatally, at the University of Alabama-Huntsville on Friday. In 1986, she killed her brother with a shotgun in Braintree, Mass., but his death was ruled an accident.

Retired Braintree Chief John Polio at first defended the handling of the case. But he said Tuesday he has “myriad” concerns about a report on it.

The now 87-year-old Polio said there were no ballistics tests included. He also thought it odd that there was an 11-day gap between the death and interviews with family members, apparently because they were too distraught to talk sooner.

THIS IS A BREAKING NEWS UPDATE. Check back soon for further information. AP’s earlier story is below.

HUNTSVILLE, Ala. (AP) — A professor who survived a deadly university shooting rampage said the colleague charged in the attack methodically shot her victims in the head until the gun apparently jammed and she was pushed out of the room.

Associate professor Joseph Ng told The Associated Press on Tuesday he was one of 12 people at a biology department meeting Friday at the University of Alabama-Huntsville. He described the details in an e-mail to a colleague at the University of California-Irvine.

Ng said the meeting had been going on for about half an hour when Amy Bishop “got up suddenly, took out a gun and started shooting at each one of us. She started with the one closest to her and went down the row shooting her targets in the head.”

Bishop, a Harvard-educated neurobiologist, was arrested and charged with one count of capital murder and three counts of attempted murder.

Killed were Gopi K. Podila, the chairman of the Department of Biological Sciences, and professors Adriel Johnson and Maria Ragland Davis. Two were wounded — professor Joseph Leahy remained in critical condition and staffer Stephanie Monticciolo was in serious condition Tuesday. The third, Luis Cruz-Vera, was released from the hospital.

Ng said the meeting was held around an oval table. The six people on one side were all shot.

“The remaining 5 including myself were on the other side of the table (and) immediately dropped to the floor,” he wrote.

Ng told the AP the shooting stopped almost as soon as it started. He said the gun seemed to jam and he and others rushed Bishop out of the room and then barricaded the door shut with a table.

Ng said the charge was led by Debra Moriarity, a professor of biochemistry, after Bishop aimed the gun at her and attempted to fire. When the gun didn’t shoot, Moriarity pushed her way to Bishop, urged her to stop, and then helped force her out the door.

“Moriarity was probably the one that saved our lives. She was the one that initiated the rush,” he told the AP. “It took a lot of guts to just go up to her.”

Ng said the survivors worried she would shoot her way through the door, and frantically worked up a backup plan in case she burst through. But she never did.

“There was a time when I didn’t think I’d come out of the room alive,” he said. “I don’t think any of us thought we’d come out alive.”

Investigators haven’t commented on a possible motive, but Bishop was vocal about her displeasure over being denied tenure by the university, forcing her to look for work elsewhere after this semester.

Some victims’ relatives have also questioned how Bishop was hired at the university in 2003 after she was involved years ago in separate criminal probes. University of Alabama officials were meeting privately to review the files concerning her hiring.

In 1986, Bishop shot and killed her 18-year-old brother with a shotgun at their Braintree, Mass., home. She told police at the time that she had been trying to learn how to use the gun, which her father had bought for protection, when it accidentally discharged.

Authorities released her and said the episode was a tragic accident. She was never charged. The Norfolk County district attorney at the time was William Delahunt, now a Democratic congressman from Massachusetts. He was traveling in Israel and could not immediately be reach for comment on the case.

John Kivlan, the former assistant district attorney who reviewed the case, told The Associated Press on Tuesday that there was nothing then to indicate Seth Bishop’s death was anything but an accident. He said a joint investigation by state and local police as well as the medical examiner’s office all came to that conclusion.

Current Braintree police Chief Paul Frazier questions how the investigation was handled. Frazier said Amy Bishop also fired once into a wall before hitting her brother, then fired a third time into the ceiling.

Bishop’s husband, James Anderson, said Monday he had known about her brother being shot, but said “it was an accident. That’s all I knew about it.”

An auto mechanic who worked at a dealership near Bishop’s home in 1986 told The Boston Globe that Bishop ran in after shooting her brother, waved a gun and demanded a getaway car.

Tom Pettigrew, 45, recalled that Bishop said she had had a fight with her husband and he was going to come after her, so she needed to flee. Pettigrew said Braintree police briefly questioned him and several other employees, but authorities never contacted him again.

Kivlan, who is now retired and living in Sarasota, Fla., said he did not recall that element of the case.

“I am not saying it didn’t happen, but for whatever reason it wasn’t included in his report,” Kivlan said. “Even if we knew about that it may not have changed things.”

Then in 1993, Bishop and her husband were questioned by investigators looking into a pipe bomb sent to one of Bishop’s colleagues, Dr. Paul Rosenberg, at Children’s Hospital Boston. The bomb did not go off, and nobody was ever charged.

Anderson defended himself and his wife as innocent people questioned by investigators casting a wide net. He said the case “had a dozen people swept up in this and everybody was a subject, not a suspect.”

“There was never any indictment, arrest, nothing, and then everyone was cleared after five years,” he said.

Huntsville police spokesman Sgt. Mark Roberts said his department didn’t find out about either of the older cases until after the shooting on campus. He said police were checking to confirm details of the pipe bomb probe.

Anderson said his wife had practiced at a shooting range not long before the shooting. Anderson said she acted normally while they were at the range and none of her behavior in recent days foreshadowed Friday’s rampage.

“She was just a normal professor,” he told The Associated Press during an interview at his home Monday.

Anderson said his wife didn’t reveal why she took an interest in guns. He knew she had a gun, but didn’t know when or where she got the weapon.

“I really don’t know how she got it, or where she got it from,” he said.

Police have said Bishop had no permit for the gun they believe she used in the campus shooting, and investigators said they didn’t know where she got it. It’s unclear if it was the same gun that her husband knew about.

Associated Press Writers Bob Johnson in Montgomery, Mark Pratt in Boston and Stephen Singer in Hartford, Conn., contributed to this report.